Effective midnight tonight, the economic and commercial landscapes of India will undergo a paradigm shift. The biggest indirect tax reform since independence, the Goods, and Services Tax (GST) is going to come into force. 17 indirect taxes, 33 different kinds of levies and cess, the never-ending harassment of business owners by the tax authorities not to mention the constant rent seeking by the police at state border check posts, all this will hopefully become history as the whole country will become a common market with a flat rate of tax across the board. This is a huge leap of faith in the dark because nothing like this has ever been done before in this country. This GST is by no means ideal or perfect and it will remain a work in progress, tweaked here and there as we go along. For the moment though the Modi government deserves to be congratulated.
Thursday, 29 June 2017
Wednesday, 28 June 2017
The word that came to my mind after reading Arundhati Roy's second novel after 20 years, 'The Ministery Of Utmost Happiness' was, ''underwhelming''. Don't get me wrong, this is not an inferior book by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, quite the opposite. I just feel she took too much on the plate as subject matter. After the luminous success of 'The God Of Small Things' two decades ago, she not only became a different kind of writer, but also a different kind of person. In the intervening years, Ms. Roy went headlong into activism and advocacy negotiating the dangerous fault lines of the modern Indian state. From Gujarat pogrom of 2002 to the insurgency in Kashmir, from resistance against big dams to the atrocities on the tribal population in India's own heart of darkness, the forests of Chhatisgarh. She has been a stellar and provocative voice on all of these and more.
What has been most remarkable about this new book is that how she has been able to bring together so many disparate elements from a nation's life together and weave a cohesive, even if at times unwieldy narrative. It is a tribute to her exceptional skill as a writer, that even though the incidents that form the backdrop of the novel are very much contemporary in nature, you just want to keep going. Especially in the section on Kashmir, the prose literally soars to new heights. Why I said ''underwhelming'' in the beginning is because for some reason, it doesn't quite capture the haunting beauty of 'The God Of Small Things', and as a great admirer of Arundhati, it kept bothering me somewhat.
What has been most remarkable about this new book is that how she has been able to bring together so many disparate elements from a nation's life together and weave a cohesive, even if at times unwieldy narrative. It is a tribute to her exceptional skill as a writer, that even though the incidents that form the backdrop of the novel are very much contemporary in nature, you just want to keep going. Especially in the section on Kashmir, the prose literally soars to new heights. Why I said ''underwhelming'' in the beginning is because for some reason, it doesn't quite capture the haunting beauty of 'The God Of Small Things', and as a great admirer of Arundhati, it kept bothering me somewhat.
Tuesday, 20 June 2017
What do you say when a genuine intellectual like Gopal Gandhi is brushed aside for somebody like Mr. Ram Nath Kovind, who is the opposite of intellectual, for the august office of the President of India. This is a piece of pathetic tokenism by the BJP in the name of Dalit empowerment. Narendra Modi and Amit Shah, both have politics on their mind 24/7. So much so that now it really feels suffocating. Every nomination and appointment made by this government has the sole focus of either this election or that election, or if not elections, then a cynical desire to have lackeys (chamchas) in important positions. How are they any different from the Congress party whom they want to obliterate from the country? At the very least, with the Congress, you could shame them into doing the right thing from time to time. The BJP of Shah-Modi combine is devoid of any shame.
Friday, 9 June 2017
A dreadful moment for the Conservative party in Britain. Prime Minister Theresa May badly miscalculated the extent of support she enjoyed among the British public. The Tories had a good thing going with a comfortable majority in parliament. But Ms. May wanted an even bigger mandate before she enters into tough Brexit negotiations with the European Union. What does she do? She calls for snap elections, and instead of shoring up her majority even further, the opposite has happened. The voters have returned a hung parliament. The Conservatives will have to form a minority government and the prime minister will have to depend on the support of the Democratic Unionist Party of Northern Ireland, one of the most extreme entities on the British Isle. Talk about being caught between a rock and a hard place.
Sunday, 4 June 2017
My first loyalty is not to India, but to the state of Bihar. And I take no pleasure in saying that the shocking results of the intermediate examinations are symptomatic of the deeper rot that has set into the education system of the state as a whole. Every year, we're just producing an army of semi-educated young men and women who are both unemployed and unemployable. Once upon a time, we used to have a very hardworking chief minister in Mr. Nitish Kumar with a progressive development-oriented agenda. He is squandering away all the goodwill by firstly, this puritanical zeal in imposing prohibition at the cost of every other important matter in the state, and secondly, the decision to enter into an alliance with a thoroughly discredited Lalu Yadav, who does not so have a political party as a gang of mercenary thugs. Bihar is crying out for deliverance from this miasma of anarchy, cynicism, and boredom.
Sunday, 28 May 2017
Western UP is burning because of caste-related violence against the Dalit communities, but this third rate clown Adityanath has been celebrating the birthday of 16th-century Rajput warrior king Maharana Pratap. Elsewhere, in the same state, a group of predatory boys manhandles and molest two girls, and this absolutely loathsome creep and a member of the opposition party, Azam Khan says that young women should be kept indoors most of the times! Actually, I am not surprised. Both Adityanath and Azam Khan complement each other, in fact, they feed off each other in order to provide fuel to fire their reactionary agenda.
Saturday, 27 May 2017
Even 53 years after his death, it is still fashionable in a large section of the middle classes in India to abuse and crucify our first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru for all the ills afflicting the Republic of India. In their incoherent and unfocused anger, people lose all kinds of perspective. They don’t appreciate the fact that if India today feels like an oasis of calm amidst the arid landscape of general chaos and disorder of South Asia, a major part of the credit must go to Mr. Nehru. Because he believed in his heart of heart, that whatever shapes the newly independent nation may take, it will never be the mirror image of Pakistan. Even his most uncompromising critics would have to concede that history has proved him more right than wrong. We have seen what happens in the creation of Bangladesh and the horrible civil war in Sri Lanka; the terrible consequences of imposing a majoritarian culture on a diverse population. Our first prime minister was nothing if not a true democrat. He never shied away from engaging with his political opponents, both inside and outside parliament, on every issue of national importance. Today, if we have acquired even a modicum of scientific and technological achievement to our credit, it was only thanks to Nehru’s untiring zeal and passion in nurturing the institutions and backing the scientific community.
Of course, I would be remiss in my assessment if I don’t say that he also made some errors of judgment along the way. But then, what human being is immune to making mistakes? The thing about hindsight is that it gives us 20/20 vision. His too much faith in the command economy which ended up creating state monopoly in every walk of life. His inability to reform the personal laws of the Muslim community like he was able to do in the case of the Hindus. His romantic but naïve belief in the brotherhood of India and China. His spectacular miscalculations on Kashmir. These are some that come to mind. We cannot pass a definitive judgment of why he did what he did because we were not there. We simply cannot compare the current situation in the country with what was the state of play in the early years of independence. It can be said without reservations that Nehru laid the foundation of a modern, open and secular India. If the current political discourse in India is characterized by crassness, vulgarity, and cruelty, we cannot hold Nehru accountable. Pt. Nehru didn’t introduce dynasty and nepotism in Indian public life. His daughter Indira did, that too after he was gone. When he was incarcerated for nearly three years by the British in the wake of the Quit India movement; in the prison he requested the authorities for some loose sheaf of papers and pen, and then went on to write ‘Discovery of India’, one of the most definitive works on the much devalued, not to mention much-discredited term nowadays, the ‘idea of India’. Nehru was a statesman and not merely a politician. He didn’t just think about the next election, but also about the next generation. He was a true internationalist and an intellectual prime minister. Of course, he did not get everything right. But then who ever did? In the ultimate analysis, he got more thing right than he got wrong, and that should be good enough. Once, he said that as long as he is alive, he will not allow India to become a Hindu Pakistan. And thank God for that!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
#241
As they say, one should be gracious in victory and generous in defeat. So, let me be generous enough in admitting that this sledgehammer o...
-
I know for a fact that in India, people make too much fuss about your capacity to be an emotionally balanced human being if you have been ...
-
A scandalous financial skullduggery takes place more than two decades ago. It takes 10 years to frame charges. A further 10 years of mean...
-
Not many people realize, but the 9th of May has to be a red-letter day in the annals of women's emancipation. For it was on this day in...