The other day, the Prime minister was telling the students
at a university in Banaras about the virtues of being young and free-minded
individuals they have to become if the country has to move forward. Maybe the grotesque irony of the situation
was completely lost on him. Because just
a couple of days before that, there was a brutal crackdown on a group of students
by the police on the campus of one of the premier liberal arts university in
the country, the JNU in the capital New Delhi.
Their supposed crime was that they were chanting 'anti India/anti
national' slogans. This peaceful agitation
so unnerved the government about the imminent collapse of the mighty Indian
state that it used methods which was grossly disproportionate to the so called
'treasonous act' by a handful of disaffected youngsters. Anyone not familiar with the devious high-handedness
of the Indian state would have thought this something out of a banana republic!
There is a basic
problem with the attitude of the government.
They believe that they have a monopoly over what constitute nationalism
and patriotism. When you start defining these
nebulous and subjective facets of community life into a rigid structure of your
ideological value system; then it is a very short step before your patriotism turns
into a worldview grounded in jingoism, reaction and half-truths, that can do
incalculable damage to this country. To
me, the freedom of speech and expression is absolute and non-negotiable. I must have the right to express my views without
any fear, and this also includes the freedom to mock and ridicule any religion
or nationality, and if in the process, somebody's sentiments are offended, so
be it. As long as people are not indulging
in violent activities, why can't the government just let us be? Even the Constitution has not defined
nationalism and has left it to the individual's devices. I am much more concerned about the health of
the Republic which need to be guarded against the growing virus of intolerance.